Monday, May 7, 2012

Suit or Sari? On Professionalism and 'Ethnic' Dressing

I had the pleasure to attend a women's leadership conference this past weekend. It was a fantastic opportunity to meet innovative and dynamic women from seven different decades, and I was so inspired by much that I saw and heard.

But it was a lecture by a popular professor -- an expert in public speaking and issues of gender and communication -- that left me unexpectedly troubled. And it's taken me a couple days to figure out why.

I last saw this professor lecture more than 20 years ago - and she's still the same funny, sharp-witted, and insightful speaker I remember from back in my college days. She urged us conference participants to be assertive, not aggressive, in our speech, to think about standing and sitting with confidence, to avoid lilting upward at the end of our sentences, to resist being cut off by others while we're speaking.

All of this made a lot of sense to me. I know that women are often taught to defer to others in conversation ("no, no, you go ahead"), that we may unconsciously adopt physical postures of passivity or childishness (the cocked head, the crossed leg stance while standing), that we may sound as if we're apologizing, for even our names ("my name is Sayantani??").

And yet, when the lecture got to the issue of dressing for presentation success, I began to feel distinctly uncomfortable.

"Don't wear skirts that are too short," she said, "And -- man or woman,  if you're planning on crossing your leg at the ankle (a gesture men often do), please wear calf-high socks. There's nothing as distracting as a hairy leg - female or male."

Ok, no hairy crossed legs, check. Seemed simple and logical enough. 

"Don't wear patterns, scarves, obvious jewelery or dangling earrings -- they distract from your face and your message," she urged.

Ok, I guess I could see that, I thought, thinking dubiously of the patterned scarf I was wearing, as well as the embroidered Indian top, the gold paisley shaped earrings - also from India.

"Don't wear patterned clothing - I stick mostly to black, and perhaps one solid color to pop," the lecturer added. She was wearing black pants and a red blazer.


That was the advice that continued to bother me. After all, just the night before, at the conference's formal gala, I was among one of few women in ethnic dress (a salwaar kameese, dupatta, and fancy jacket), and got nothing but compliments. It's a deliberate gesture of ethnic pride I often make at formal occassions, but it's also a practical one - my nicest and most dressy clothes are usually Indian clothes.

Over the next few days, I began to wonder -  do such pieces of advice eliminate personal style - either regarding speaking or dressing? Do they mandate an appearance of ethnic homogeneity? I mean, did Aung Sung Suu Kyyi or Winnie Mandela or Indira Gandhi (all powerful global women leaders and speakers) avoid patterns and jewels? In this rapidly shrinking global world, was it possible for all women to dress alike anyway?

I approach this issue through a particular lens, of course, that of a woman of color, but also a woman whose parents are immigrants. I am also a woman who watched my own mother, who came to this country at the age of 19 and was quite a jeans-and-beads wearing hippie for a number of years, stop wearing Western clothes altogether. It was shortly after the racist 'dotbuster' incidents in New Jersey -- when a group of thugs who declared themselves to be 'dotbusters' were terrorizing people of Indian origin. My mother, determined to show solidarity and pride in her identity, went cold turkey - no more jeans, no more Western clothes. She's a widely known academic and activist, and often does public lectures and trainings and yet - she's always dressed in either a salwaar kamesee or sari, with, yes, a bindi on her forehead.

Now, I understand, both my mother, and now, I , are academics and there are obviously different expectations regarding dress and public presentation in many professions. Corporate America or television journalism are less forgiving re: presentation style than a university, or a creative business. Yet, I have an aunt who is an attorney who has developed her own style of professional dressing for the courtroom - a dark colored cotton sari topped by a suit jacket. And obviously, corporate women in India and other countries surely wear different styles of professional dress.

I too am usually found with at least one piece of Indian clothing on my body - a flowing kurta on top of dark pants, topped by a blazer or jacket. It's my style, my interpretation of professorial dress codes, and I think, like my mother, it also reflects something political -- an identification with my roots and origins that I'm not willing to give up.

Might a woman wearing a sari at a podium get a different reception than a woman wearing a dark suit? Perhaps. I guess it depends if the podium is in New York or Topeka, Washington or New Dilli. But isn't that difference in reception one worth challenging and interrogating?

I guess my point is - ethnic dressing, like standing straight, meeting people in the eye when I talk, and not apologizing for my point of view, is actually a form of assertive communication on my part. It's a personal choice - just as any other woman's style of professional presentation is her personal choice.

And honestly, even if  if I dress like Hillary Clinton or Madeline Albright, no one's going to be mistaking me for them any time soon. If people are prejudiced against me for dressing ethnically, will they be any less so if I put my brown skin and Indian face in Western clothing? I hazard an assertive no.

Like the question mark I keep trying to keep off the end of my sentences, I don't want to apologize for looking, and sounding, like exactly who I am.

41 comments:

  1. people should wear what they're comfortable wearing. those who judge on the basis of clothing are rarely worth hearing. if women get to wear only what they or men think will make women fit in among men, then women will never be equal (likewise, nor will indians, africans, or whatever other nationality that might be forced to conform to euro-american fashions). what could be more awesome than a business as richly and diversely attired as nature itself?

    of course, i say this as someone who varies between suits and jeans at work, and who has tattoos down to his wrists...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Clearly, I agree Dr. Geraci! (while recognizing that folks have to put dinner on the table and pay the mortgage and may not have a lot of room in their, say, insurance company or whatever to make political statements... not to mention of course folks who are required to wear a uniform to work...)

    ReplyDelete
  3. What a wonderful post - thanks for sharing

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As an American expat in India - and in a location where we're often asked to dress in Indian attire (my wardrobe defaults to salwar suits, with saris for formal events) - the idea of being able to dress respectably and respectfully in these clothes is important to me. I consider it a high compliment when I'm told that I walk naturally and look good in my saris; the Western idea of "fashion" and "business dress" simply cannot, and often does not, take into account the views and other cultures that exist.

    It's not just a form of communication, but also respecting the culture you're in (in my case) or acknowledging your heritage; the idea that it might be inappropriate or unprofessional simply smacks of ethnocentrism to me.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for your comments, hijabeng and pahariyommem! Great points about clothing requirements and ethnocentrism, many thanks for making them!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dressing inside all likely program and also stay the particular fashion offers turned directly into a great must pertaining to everybody,no matter if you are likely to be able to firm in addition in a good night coffee dining room table party as well as a time in just about all your own better half,every consumer desires for you to Produce a brilliant impact and just for this fashion participate in the extremely essential perform to supply a person appear in addition to feel.

    Womens suit dress

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thank you for the beautiful information you have shared .It is helping me a lot.INDIANTHEME is the platform that provides you the dealers who can provide you some best deals that will be very beneficial to you definitely.
    To get the dealings in Indian Ethnic Wear
    , Designer sarees and many more So just visit www.indiantheme.com and get more benefits in your dealing.You will get to know that how easy and how conveniently you can buy your willing article in just a single click.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I concede, I have not been on this website page in quite a while... in any case it was another bliss to see It is such a vital theme and disregarded by such a large number of, even experts. experts. I thank you to help making individuals more mindful of conceivable issues. hairstyles for women

    ReplyDelete
  10. Quite impressing topic and it is beautifully described. The most important thing is, to Buy Indian Sarees Online is a very easy task nowadays.

    ReplyDelete
  11. suit and saree are differnt but perfect for any occassions for every occassion there is a saree like party sarees , south indian saree, wedding saree etc and even salwar

    ReplyDelete
  12. If you are finding ethnic wear for female in India then freeclues.com is the right choice, the silhouettes, fabrics and style have attracted the modern Indian woman who is willing to explore. It provides the youth with an array of styles and experiment to their hearts content, and at affordable prices. For more details:https://freeclues.com/

    ReplyDelete
  13. Awesome post about the dressing styles for women. I really like this blog. I recommend to continue to write many more topics on south indian sarees, wedding sarees online, premium sarees, office wear sarees to drive more visitors to your blog. Thanks for sharing!!

    ReplyDelete
  14. A writer should always try to keep its writing very simple and clear. Always use facts which are easily acceptable by general people because they are very close to their assumptions and they welcome such kind of facts.เสื้อสูท

    ReplyDelete
  15. Wow, Very nice information‼ It's really great because we need such type of information for our daily life … Here I am also provide the relevant information such as Women Ethnic Kurti.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Wow, Very nice information‼ It's really great because we need such type of information for our daily life … Here I am also provide the relevant information such as Women Ethnic Kurti.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nice post! Aurelia kurta that has wide range of collection for women's.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Printed kurtis are best to wear in every season. Buy now the awesome cost Cotton Printed kurtis Online at feasible price.

    ReplyDelete
  19. If you want to get Rajasthani Wedding Dresses then these dresses are available at Rajvesh only. Buy now.

    ReplyDelete
  20. A nice post about online ethnic sarees wear. Thanks a lot for sharing new type of saree attire in India.

    https://www.ethnickart.com/category/sarees/986/

    ReplyDelete
  21. This is the first time I came to this blog and I found some relevant stuff here. Basically I keen to know new parameters of writing every-time and sometime it become really very hard to find such kind of platform.
    กระเป๋าสตางค์ผู้หญิง

    ReplyDelete

  22. flipkart coupan,
    flipkart coupon code,
    flipkart coupon code for hdfc credit card,
    flipkart coupon code for icici credit card,
    flipkart coupon code for mobile,
    flipkart coupon code for mobile app,
    flipkart coupon code for mobile phones,
    flipkart coupon code for new user,
    flipkart coupon code today,
    flipkart coupon for today,
    flipkart coupon hdfc credit card,
    flipkart coupons,
    flipkart coupons citibank,
    flipkart coupons for axis bank,
    flipkart coupons for citibank credit card,
    flipkart coupons for credit card,
    flipkart coupons for hdfc credit card,,
    flipkart coupons for hdfc debit card,
    flipkart coupons for icici bank,
    flipkart coupons for icici card,
    flipkart coupons for icici credit card,
    flipkart coupons for icici debit card,
    flipkart coupons for mobile phones,
    flipkart coupons for mobile phones 2016,
    flipkart coupons for mobiles,
    flipkart coupons for sbi credit card,
    flipkart coupons for sbi debit card,
    flipkart coupons for shoes,
    flipkart coupons for watches,
    flipkart coupons hdfc,
    flipkart coupons hdfc bank,
    flipkart coupons icici,
    flipkart coupons purchase,,
    flipkart coupons today
    flipkart cashback offer,
    flipkart axis cashback offer,
    flipkart discount coupon codes
    flipkartcashbackoffers,
    flipkart sbi cashback offers,
    flipkart cashback offers on mobiles,
    big billion day offers flipkart cashback,
    cashback offers flipkart,
    flipkart exchange offers on mobiles,
    flipkart cashback,
    flipkart cashback june,
    flipkart cashback offers,
    flipkart offers toady,
    flipkart bank cashback offer,
    flipkart cashback offers on watches,
    flipkart cashback offers on fashion,
    flipkart big billion day cashback offers,
    flipkart cashback may,
    flipkart big billion day offers 2017,
    flipkart deal of the day offers,
    flipkart christmas cashback offers,
    flipkart hdfc cashback,
    flipkart hdfc cashback offers,
    flipkart coupons,
    flipkart offers,
    flipkart offers cashback,
    flipkart offers 2017,
    flipkart axis bank offer,
    flipkart cashback february,
    flipkart cashback offers on washing,
    flipkart big billion day offers,
    flipkart hdfc cashback on electronics,
    flipkart offers on moblies,
    flipkartcashbackoffers,
    flipkart citi bank offers,
    flipkart cashback april,
    flipkart daily offers,
    flipkart yes cashback offer,
    flipkart today offers,
    flipkart discount offers on kitchen,
    flipkart cashback on home appliances,
    flipkart discount offers,
    flipkart deals today,
    flipkart cashback on mobiles,
    flipkart cashback offers on sarees,
    flipkart hdfc offer,
    flipkart cashback january,
    flipkart cashback offers on home,
    flipkart phonepe cashback offer,
    flipkart credit card offers,
    flipkart republic day sale offers,
    flipkart promo codes,
    flipkart cashback on refrigerators,
    flipkart upcoming offers in 2018,
    flipkart sbi offers,
    flipkart hdfc offer on mobiles,
    flipkart sbi offer cashback,
    flipkart debit card offers,
    flipkart phonepe offers, flipkart cashback coupons,
    flipkart citi bank offer,
    flipkart coupons 2018,
    flipkart citi bank offer on electronics,
    flipkart cashback on air conditioners,
    flipkart mobiles offers,
    flipkart iphone offers,
    flipkart hdfc bank offers,
    flipkart offers today,
    flipkart discounts on laptops,
    flipkart exchange offers,
    flipkart sbi cashback offer,
    big trillion day offers flipkart ,
    flipkart citi bank cashback offers,
    flipkart cashback offers 2018,
    flipkart hdfc offers,
    flipkart axis bank offers,
    flipkart air conditioner offers
    flipkart offers on televisions,
    flipkart refrogiratiors offers,
    flipkart sbi offer,
    flipkart daily deals,
    flipkart phonepe cashback offers,
    flipkart cashback offers,
    flipkart offers on laptops,
    flipkart new year cashback offers,
    flipkart emi offers,
    flipkart sbi offers on electronics

    ReplyDelete
  23. Nice information!
    Discover Latest Collection Women Festive Wear Online . Keep their culture alive by celebrating festivals with Indian festive wear

    ReplyDelete
  24. Check Some today’s <a href="https://www.jovifashion.com/shop/apparels/set-of-3-11.html”> Trendy Festive apparels </a> or dresses for women such as Anarkali dress, floral dresses, Angrakha Style kurta, iKat Kurta, Midi Dress, women maxi Dress, Women Top Wear, Women Bottom Wear, Top & Shirts, Kurtas & Sets, etc

    ReplyDelete
  25. Explore the Latest new designer Clothing women Collection . Check out all type of women outfits as Suit-sets, pants, Palazzo, Dresses, top wear, bottom wear etc.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Salwar suits are still trending. This is a very important and helpful post. Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Very informative blog. Thanks for sharing!! Explore latest collection of party wears sarees

    ReplyDelete

  28. I just read your post on Saree Collections and thought you made some really great points. I especially liked your take on Directgharpe If you have a chance, I’d love it if you’d take a look at my blog partywearsareeI think it might be of interest to your readers. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Both Indian sarees and suits are best. Thank you for sharing this wonderful post with us.

    ReplyDelete